The “What If” Game

Some people can get away with playing the “what if” game and come out okay. Those people tend to be optimists. 


“What if something remarkable happens today?” 

“What if I land the job of my dreams?”

“What if I met someone today who would change my life?”


That’s not how I play the “what if” game. My “what if” tends to look more like this:


“What if I’m late to work and no one ever trusts me again?”

“What if I go on this date and he turns out to be a stalker?”

“What if I host a party and I don’t have enough chairs set up and everyone hates it and hates me?”

“What if I post something on social media or on this blog that ends up getting used against me in some way?”

“What if I buy this thing I want and can afford but then later some disaster strikes and I need this money for something else?”

“What if these bad days/weeks turn into a full blown depressive episode?”


I’m REALLY good at coming up with “what if” scenarios. Too good for my own good.

Recently I came across an Instagram post that has stuck in my head. If I had known just how much it would stick, I would’ve made a note of who posted it, so I could credit them. Hindsight is 20/20 and I don’t have the information to properly give credit for this. 

The gist of the post was this:

Instead of saying “what if”, say “even if”.

Excuse me. Hold up a moment while Amelia’s brain reboots.

That is supremely simple and unambiguously profound. 

I may not be able to convince my brain to stop considering every possible future scenario. You know what I can do? Move past the fear of “what if” and turn it into the confidence of “even if”.


“Even if I’m late to work, I will be able to manage the embarrassment. Even if I am late to work and cause problems for myself, I am capable of addressing those problems.”

“Even if I go on this date and he turns out to be a stalker (or it’s a horrible date or I puke during dinner, etc. etc. etc.), I know I have a support system I can turn to for help.”

“Even if I host a party and everyone hates it (which, really Amelia, is unlikely–not everyone is going to have a blast, but it is equally unlikely that everyone will hate it), I know that I still have friends who love me and care for me. Even if things go poorly, I can learn from my mistakes.”

“Even if I post something on social media or this blog that turns out to bite me in the butt, my self-worth is not tied to the approval of strangers on the internet.”1

“Even if I experience financial hardship because of a reckless purchase (or several reckless purchases), I know that I have planned and continue to plan for rainy days. Even if those rainy days come and take me by surprise, I will be able to rebuild.”

“Even if this slump turns into a full blown depressive episode, I will survive. It will suck. It might be several years before I feel better. And I will make it through that just like I’ve made it through every time before now.”


I have been in the whole mental health school of hard knocks for years. Literally decades. I have encountered so very many different coping techniques and skills and such. Some of them have been effective. Some of those that are effective are only effective if I can implement them, and I’m not always in a place where I can actually implement them (when you are low enough, some coping skills become inaccessible). A lot of them are marginally effective for me, and to try to do ALL of them is simply impossible.

But this? This I can do. This is something my brain actually buys into. I’m not desperately trying to pretend hard enough that I force my brain to believe it. 

I. Can. Do. This.

To the internet stranger who shared that piece of wisdom: Thank you. 

  1. I’ll be honest, I’m struggling to change this into a good “even if”, because what I fear most in writing this blog is not whether people judge me but if I inadvertently reveal something that allows internet strangers to attack me in person or my real-life reputation. Not sure what my “even if” would be in that case. ↩︎

Leave a comment